Nursing Baby and Color and Limits of Acceptability?

One teacher I work with regularly and another photographer that I admire both feel strongly that color is too graphic for fine art nudes. The teacher would have me believe that the photograph isn’t art unless it’s classically black and white. The photographer friend just likes classic photographs. What can I say? I like color. I like this image in color partly because the background colors are so vivid–the grass and the pond. Also I think it’s warmer and softer more fitting for the subject matter. Black and white begins to feel distant and old-fashioned for me.

Here’s the black and white version.

babysm

Ah, but there’s another problem with this image. What is our tolerance for photos of nursing mothers? I was thinking we’re more OK with fine art nudes than nursing mothers until my husband reminded me that Elle just did a cover photo of a mother nursing her babe. It’s a supermodel mother who looks ten times better than the rest of us when we’re doing the mom-thing but it is probably groundbreaking none the less. AND IT’S IN COLOR!!!

ellesm

So here are the questions?

Color or black and white?

Nursing mom is OK? or are we still uptight about that one?

I’m hoping your join in this informal poll by leaving a comment.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *